Dr. med. Bernhard
Weber
16.7.2014
Deutschhausstr.28
35037 Marburg
Mitglied im Vorstand des ZAEN, Mitglied Erfahrungsheilkunde
Mitteilung an die Redaktionen
Mitteilung an alle Naturheilkunde Gesellschaften
Welt Naturheilkunde Förderation in Paris gegründet.
Die 2. Internationale Konferenz Naturheilkunde Medizin (ICNM) in
Paris mit ihren 250 Mitgliedern aus über 40 Ländern war der
glänzende Rahmen für die Neugründung der Welt
Naturheilkunde Förderation.(World Naturopathic Federation)
Die sehr unterschiedlichen Bedingungen von erfreulicher Förderung
bis zu Bekämpfung und Unterdrückung von Naturheilkunde
durch Regierungen und Universitäten in den verschieden Ländern
der Welt wurde vom Eröffnungsredner Dr. David Schleich, dem
Präsidenten der NCNM in USA, als wesentlicher Grund für die
Neugründung der Welt Naturheilkunde Föderation genannt.
Während Länder wie Indien, China aber auch die USA
besonders durch wissenschaftliche Forschung, aber Integration in das
Gesundheitswesen vorbildliche Möglichkeiten aufzeigen fehlt
besonders in reichen Ländern wie Deutschland diese Förderung
auch im Bereich der Forschung leider weitgehend. Länder wie die
Schweiz konnten durch Volksentscheid die Regierung zwingen
Naturheilverfahren allen interessierten Patienten zugänglich zu
machen.
Folgende Ziele stellt sich die Welt Naturheilkunde Föderation:
- Unterstützung des
Wachstums und der Vielfalt der Naturheilkunde.
- Unterstützung
bei der Anerkennung von Naturheilverfahren
- Förderung der
Verbreitung und der bestmöglichen Bildungsstandards für
unseren weltweiten Beruf .
- Förderung der
naturheilkundlichen Forschung
- Aufbau und Pflege einer
Datenbank für Naturheil Organisationen, Regulierung,
Akkreditierung, Konferenzen und Forschungsaktivitäten.
-
Arbeiten mit Welt Organisationen (Weltgesundheitsorganisation,
Vereinte Nationen, UNESCO) und den nationalen Regierungen, um
naturheilkundliche Medizin zu fördern.
Sprachliche Probleme bei über 40 teilnehmenden Nationen
wurden wurde bei den Hauptvorträgen der dreitägigen
Konferenz durch Übersetzung von Französisch ins Englische
und umgekehrt gelöst. Die zwei deutschen Referenten stellten
ihre Themen, jeweils nach kurzer Darstellung der Naturheilkunde in
Deutschland, in Englisch vor. Die ca. 80 deutschen Zeitschriften für
Naturheilverfahren für Patienten, Heilpraktiker und Ärzte
bleibt so dem Rest der Welt größtenteils verborgen. Auch
die vielen Organisationen der Naturheilkunde Therapeuten in
Deutschland sind so weltweit meist unbekannt. Wesentliches Wissen und
die zahlreichen Neuentwicklungen der ca. 30 000 Heilpraktiker und
etwa 40 000 Ärzte mit den Zusatzbezeichnungen Akupunktur,
Homöopathie, Naturheilverfahren und den über 100 Verfahren
die von des Behörden noch geringer geachtet werden bleiben so
auf Deutschland begrenzt.
Der nächste Internationale Kongress ist für 2016
geplant. Deutsche Organisationen die dieses Projekt fördern
können dies als Supporting Partners unterstützen, bisher
sind hier weltweit ca. 90 gelistet, bisher kostenfrei.
Ein 120 seitiger Sammelband der Abstracts, Referentenliste und des
Programms kann angefordert werden, notfalls bei mir für die
Kopierkosten. Meinen Vortrag über die erfolgreiche
Arterioskleroserückbildung kann per mail als Präsentation
mit 110 seitigem Begleittext „Chronical ill“ kostenlos
angefordert werden.
Falls Ihre Organisation schon englische Texte besitzt würde
ich diese gerne an die Welt Naturheilkunde Förderation
weiterleiten.
Dr. med. Bernhard Weber
Die Förderation
Constitution
& Bylaws for
World
Naturopathic Federation
NOTE:
These have been drafted based on other world federations. The points
of discussion are where federations take different approaches to how
they are structured. These areas which we must decide on are
highlighted by boxed discussion points below:
Mission
Supporting
the growth and diversity of naturopathic medicine worldwide.
Supporti
ng the regulation of naturopathic medicine
Promoting
accreditation and the highest in educational standards for our
global profession
Encouraging
naturopathic research
Establishing
and maintaining a database of Naturopathic organizations,
regulation, accreditation, conferences and research activities.
Work
with world agencies (World Health
Organisation, United Nations, UNESCO) and national governments in
order to promote naturopathic medicine.
Incorporation
Establish
a headquarters in (TBD].
DISCUSSION
POINT 1 – Location of incorporation
Option
1:
Luxembourg: Advantages
– close to global health hubs (e.g. Geneva, Brussels). Friendly
incorporation laws. Convenient for European members. Disadvantages
– Distant to North, Central and South Americans, Asia, Africa,
Australasia.
Option
2:
North America (Canada, ie. Toronto): Advantages
– HIghes accreditation standard, broadest scope of practice.
Easy access to resources and donors. Convenient for North American
members. Disadvantages
– Distant to South American, Asian, African, Australasian
members. Distant from global health hubs
Option
3:
Other – international federations are also established in China
(Beijing [Chinese medicine, Acupuncture]), Europe (London
[Physiotherapy], The Hague [Pharmacy]), USA (Chicago [Osteopathy]).
Implement
a Global Congress of Naturopathic Medicine in conjunction with a
member nation on a rotational basis between continents.
Constitution
(proposed)
(again
please comment on boxed areas only)
Members:
Representation
[General
Assembly] (Or other term if more suitable)
There
shall be a governing body known as the [General Assembly], which
shall be composed of Full member bodies of the [Federation] and shall
hold general meetings as and when the [Federation] may determine.
Each body member shall be responsible for the expenses incurred by
its designated representative in attending the meetings of the
[Federation]. All assemblies shall be open to all members. It is
proposed each Assembly will be held at each Global Congress
(Conference) of Naturopathic Medicine, which will rotate between
continents.
<Note:
detailed by-laws are jurisdiction specific and ordinarily based on
standard templates. This section will discuss the details that feed
into these templates>
Quorum
At
all annual meetings of the [Federation], a quorum shall consist of
51% [or as legally mandated in jurisdiction] of the eligible voting
members in attendance or by proxy.
Decisions
Decisions
shall be by a simple majority of [General Assembly] members present
and voting, unless otherwise stated for specific decisions (for
example for admission and termination of memberships). In the absence
of a representative, a member body may express its views in writing.
Full
members (voting rights)
Full
members shall be legally constituted national naturopathic medicine
or naturopathy associations that are broadly representative of the
practitioners of their country by virtue of their membership, with
their voting membership being limited to naturopathic practitioners
and naturopathic students. They are not subject to, or controlled by,
any office or agency of government (i.e. are
voted by, run for and governed by naturopathic practitioners in the
interests of the naturopathic profession).
Full
member organisations must: 1) have a commitment
to levels of training commensurate with delivery of primary care
services in their country; 2) have a commitment to achieving
statutory/govenment licensure or regulation in their country to
ensure appropriate levels of accountability and standards in their
respective country, and 3) have a commitment to World Health
Organization principles around professionalization.
DISCUSSION
POINT TWO – what constitutes a national association? (examples
taken from other federations)?
Minimum
number of practitioners [e.g. 50 in Acupuncture, 30 in Chinese
medicine]
Minimum
national representation of practitioners [e.g. 6% in Nursing
federation]
Minimum
level of existence [e.g. 3 years in Acupuncture, 1 year in Chinese
medicine]
Minimum
level of practitioner governance [e.g. ‘majority governed by
practitioners’ in Physiotherapy]
DISCUSSION
POINT THREE – what should a general assembly of national
associations look like?
Option
1
– “One country, one vote” (or equivalent –
e.g. two votes for each nation): Each national member association has
equal voting rights in the Assembly. [Adopters: Medicine, Public
Health, Nursing, Physiotherapy]
Option
2
– “Proportional representation”: National
associations have more votes, based on pre-determined scales. The
following is an example from the Pharmacy Association - 249 members
or less: 1 vote; 250-499 members: 2 votes; 500-999 members: 3 votes;
1000-1999: 4 votes; 2000-2999 members: 5 votes; 3000-4999 members: 6
votes; 5000-9999 members: 7 votes; 10000-19999 members: 8 votes;
20000-29999 members: 9 votes; over 30000 members: 10 votes.
[Adopters: Chinese medicine, Acupuncture, Chiropractic, Pharmacy,
Dentistry]
Option
3
– “Hybrid model”: National associations get minimum
guaranteed votes. Largest association gets small bundle of extra
votes. Additional votes can be granted to larger associations.
[Adopter: Osteopathy]
Option
4.
Other model.
DISCUSSION
POINT FOUR – should more than one organisation per country be
allowed as a Full member?
Option
1
– Absolute No. [Adopters: Medicine, Nursing, Physiotherapy].
Only
largest association allowed to join.
Option
2
– Default No. Special dispensations considered. Must share
nation vote on consensus. [Adopters: Chiropractic, Public Health,
Dentistry]. Note:
even when supported the bar for this to occur is usually very high
and very rarely enacted. The Public Health offers the following
comment in its Constitution; “As public health associations are
designed to be an integrating force among all elements within a
country only one such body from each country shall as a rule be
recognized and admitted as a full member to the Federation. When two
or more eligible associations exist in a country, these may be
admitted with equal status as full members. In this case, they
jointly have one vote, which they lose in case of disagreement
between them.”
Option
3
– Yes. Proportional voting [Adopters: Acupuncture, Chinese
medicine, Pharmacy]. In
Pharmacy, new associations allowed only with approval from existing
members from that country.
Associate
members
Organisations
or institutions with goals and objectives that are consistent with
those of the [Federation], or are useful to the aims of the
[Federation], but who do not meet the criteria of Full Membership,
may be granted Associate Membership. Associate members pay dues but
cannot vote. They can attend meetings as observers, are encouraged to
participate on [Federation] Working groups and have access to all
materials and information the [Federation] may provide to its
members.
DISCUSSION
POINT FIVE – Associate members
Question:
Should there be Associate members at all? If yes, should there be
differing types of Associate members. Various federations allow for
regional members (e.g. State, provincial or regional associations),
individual members, corporate members, government agency members.
Should these be clearly articulated? What type should there be?
Ex: Chiro –
Corporate (Industry, schools, accrediting bodies), Individual,
Student
New
members
Admission
of new members to the Federation shall be the Decision of the General
Assembly
DISCUSSION
POINT SIX – Who should new members be voted in by?
Option
1
– General Assembly vote. Voted on only by those in attendance
at the General Assembly. [Adopters: Chiropractic, Pharmacy, Public
Health, Medicine, Physiotherapy, Dentistry]
Option
2
– Executive committee vote. Voted by the Executive on behalf of
members [Adopters: Acupuncture, Chinese medicine]
Option
3
– Postal ballot. Voted by all
members
whether in attendance or not. [Adopter: Nursing]
Option
4
– Other. For
example, Osteopathy has no formal process beyond new member
applications being ‘reviewed
DISCUSSION
POINT SEVEN – What level vote should be required for new
entrants?
Option
1
– Plain majority. [Adopters: Chiropractic, Acupuncture, Chinese
medicine, Nurses]
Option
2
– Two-thirds majority [Adopters: Pharmacy, Medicine, Public
Health, Dentistry, Physiotherapy]
Option
3
– Other
Termination
of members
Termination
of members shall be decided on the same basis as admission of new
members
Ethical
conduct
Member
organisations of the [Federation] have an obligation to maintain high
standards and to continuously advance the integrity of the
naturopathic profession. A member organisation should maintain
membership in and actively support the [Federation] and abide by its
bylaws and policies. Member organisations should respect diversity of
people, cultures, and general opinions and will strive to make
membership reflect this commitment. Any specific policies impacting
the ethical behaviour of member organizations or their delegates may
be defined in policies and bylaws. Breach of these policies and
bylaws may be grounds for termination of membership, or termination
of a delegate’s right to represent a member organisation.
Executive
Committee
The General
Assembly shall elect a President, a Vice-President, who shall be the
President-Elect, and any other officers, and appoint a Treasurer and
a Secretary General. The General Assembly shall also determine the
composition of an Executive Board and elect its members. The officers
and members of the Board shall hold office for such periods as the
General Assembly may decide.
DISCUSSION
POINT EIGHT – What should the Executive make-up look like?
Option
1
– The Executive committee should be constituted by election by
the [General Assembly] only. [Adopters: Public Health, Dentistry,
Pharmacy]
Option
2
– Regional representation. Each specific region shall have a
representative, though still voted by the General Assembly.
[Adopters: Medicine, Physiotherapy]. Usual
regions are Asia, Europe, Australasia, Africa, North America, South
America, EMRO. Otherwise by the WHO Regional Offices.
Option
3
– Regional and proportional. One member for every x members
(e.g. in Chiropractic 3,000) with regional membership to guarantee
breadth of representation. [Adopter: Chiropractic]
Option
4
– Proportional. Additional executive spots guaranteed for
largest member/s. [Adopter: Osteopathy]
Option
5
– Other. Note: Nursing
and Osteopathy distinguish between ‘streams’ of those
professions.
Remuneration
All
Executive members will serve on a voluntary, unremunerated basis. No
Officer shall be paid for his/her services, although the President
can authorise reimbursement of any actual and eligible expenses
incurred by an Officer carrying out an authorised task on behalf of
the Executive. Support staff of the Federation may be remunerated.
Committees
The
[General Assembly] and the Executive shall establish such committees
and working groups as they require.
Committees
Committees
fulfil functions serving the organisational framework of the
[Federation]. In addition to permanent Committees such as regulation,
educations, and research. The [General Assembly] or Executive may
appoint interim Committees for activities limited in time. The
structure of committees shall be established in policy.
Working
Groups
Working
Groups will usually be created to work on theme-related program
elements serving to fulfil parts of the [Federation’s] mission.
For Working Groups to be recognised by the Executive and [General
Assembly] their terms of reference, rules of procedures and a work
program have to be presented. Temporary recognition is possible to
allow for the preparation of these documents. Depending on the
situation, other terms (Task Force, Study Group, Action Group, etc.)
may be used to describe Working Groups.
<This is
to allow for conference organising Committees, development of
sub-committees to detail registration, accreditation, education
standards etc., as well as more specific governance roles>
Amendments
Amendment
to the Constitution shall be by a two-thirds majority of the General
Assembly after recommendation by the Executive.
Discussions
toward a World Naturopatic Federation
AGENDA
2nd
Day
July
5, 2014 - Saturday
7:30
AM – meet in lobby of Marriot – then move down to a
conference room TBD
DRAFT
AGENDA
2nd
Meeting
Please come prepared at this
meeting to give a short update from each of your countries.
Welcome
& Thank You’s to ICNM Board
Brief
History of How Got Important – YOUR HAVE COME AT THE RIGHT
TIME – we have been waiting for you to come – all work
thus far has been PREPATORY; no formal decision have been made.
Summary/Recap
of 1st
two days of informal talks
Recap
on 67th
World Health Organization World Health Assembly – May 2014
What
we learned – Tabatha Parker, ND & Michael Cronin, ND
WHO
Strategy on Traditional Medicine
Guiding
countries to regulate T&CM (Traditional & Complementary
Medicine) in all countries by.
From
2012 – the number of countries that are in the process or
have laws grew from x to x
Basic
Requirements
Must
be a true International Federation – with representation
from all WHO World Regions
African,
Americas (North & Latin), Eastern Mediterranean, European,
South East Asia, Western Pacific
All
Members must support Statutory/Government Regulation/
Registration/Licensure or equivalent of the profession in your
country
Member
Associations must represent the profession (ie – Voting
members cannot be an overarching group representing a broad
variety of professions)
Formal
Discussion on The Proposed International Federation of Naturopathic
Medicine
Comments
submitted by countries previously will be reviewed any items that
have consensus will not be discussed.
Constitution
& Broad Objectives
DISCUSSION
POINTS – Only sections will be discussed where there is not
consensus from previously submitted documents
Location
of Incorporation
What
Constitutes a National Association?
What
Should a General Assembly/Voting look like
Full
Member Requirements & Multiple Associations per country issues
– CANDIDATE MEMBER
Associate
members
Who
should vote in New Full Members (aka national associations)?
What
majority would be required to accept new full members
Executive
Make-up
Action
Steps
Incorporation
Next
Meeting
Formal
Letter of Intent from National Organizations
Meeting
Close
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
www.icnmnaturopathy.org
Anne
Marie Narboni, ND
Executive Congress Chair ICNM
info@livemedia.fr